Wednesday, November 8, 2017

The Complete Collapse of the Murphy/Thompson/McCarthy/Capers Era

I remember when…..The Packers won the Super Bowl, the Packers had the No. 1 quarterback in all of football (a Collinsworthism) and the Packers were ranked No. 1 in the NFL.


2017 NFL Power Rankings:
Post Offseason: 6
While Packers fans railed at Ted Thompson for initially taking his typical wait-and-see (and usually-do-nothing-but-re-sign-a-Don-Barclay) offseason, the unflappable GM didn't blink. Julius Peppers walked. Micah Hyde walked. Then Thompson pulled a surprise on the level of an Alyson Hannigan party revelation. Signing Martellus Bennett was a shocker, a splash move that doesn't mesh with Thompson's football DNA. He pulled it off big-time with Charles Woodson. Somewhat less so -- but still effectively -- with Peppers. Now Bennett. And the tight end goes from catching balls from Tom Brady to catching balls from Aaron Rodgers. Wow.
Post-Free Agency: 5 up 1
Tough to decide precisely which team should sit here in the Power Rankings. For now, we're going with the Packers, who are better at the quarterback position than the Cowboys and were able to contribute to a lineup that plays NOW, beginning with cornerback Kevin King, an outstanding pick at 33rd overall (he could've gone 10 spots earlier) who could end up starting over Davon House, or at least playing in nickel packages. Expect fellow second-round pick Josh Jones to be getting in on dime packages, as well. Third-round defensive tackle Montravius Adams should play right away, too.
Preseason: 3 up 2
If you play fantasy or opine on the occasional mutterings from head coach Mike McCarthy, then you probably think Ty Montgomery is going to put Marshall Faulk to shame this year. Tap the brakes, turbo. Don't sleep on rookie Jamaal Williams, who's already getting some first-team reps. In truth, though, with so much focus on Montgomery's acclimation to the offense, too little attention has been paid to the secondary. That's the group that killed this team in Washington and nearly lost a massive lead in Dallas. Injuries, inexperience and a few deep balls were all to blame. With one more year under the collective belt, and the ascending play of Ha Ha Clinton-Dix, the whole team should benefit. Gonna miss Micah Hyde, the human Swiss Army knife, though.
Week 1: 4 down 1
Aaron Rodgers barely played in August. Preseason football, yo. But I like what I'm seeing. All the hand-wringing about Ty Montgomery getting passed on the depth chart and losing opportunities to Jamaal Williams is going to go the same place as all those Najeh Davenport-is-gonna-run-for-1,100-yards takes: in the ... er ... trash. Depth on the offensive line and at linebacker is problematic, but the secondary -- despite popular belief -- is not.
**Week 2: 1 up 3**
Top of the charts, for now, for the Packers. Here's why:
1)
Aaron Rodgers.
2) Forget the stats.
Ty Montgomery has zero to prove in terms of handling the workload as an RB1 after running hard between the tackles against the Seahawks' formidable defensive wall.
3) The improvement in the secondary. So often,
Russell Wilson couldn't find anywhere to go with the football on Sunday, which -- as opposed to his much-maligned offensive line -- was the culprit behind the pressure he faced.
4) The
Patriots were handled Thursday night.
5)
Mike Daniels (1.5 sacks, seven tackles and several QB hits) continued to be one of the unsung premier players in the NFL.
6)
Aaron Rodgers.
Week 3: 7 down 6
The move down is more about team health than the loss to the Falcons on Sunday night. I think everyone anticipated this being a stiff road challenge for Mike McCarthy and Co. You try winning against the defending NFC champs, as they open up their new digs, without your left tackle, right tackle, top wide receiver and maybe the best defensive tackle this side of Aaron Donald. As the night wore on, Green Bay lost more players. With all those statuses potentially in question for Week 3, the Cheeseheads get down- grated.
Week 4: 10 down 3
You can't stop Geronimo Allison. The Bengals learned as much on Sunday, when a national CBS audience was introduced to his legend. Tony Romo was quite enthusiastic about Allison's catch-and-run in OT. OK, so maybe the win didn't go the way the Packers drew it up on Sunday. They were one of a handful of presumably solid teams that survived near upsets (or fell) in Week 3. Green Bay is obviously hurt by its starting offensive line not being intact. However, that means Mike McCarthy can expect improvement over the back half of the season. On that note: Rookie cornerback Kevin King is a player to circle. Another note: Aaron Rodgers is still otherworldly, pick-six included.
Week 5: 5 up 5
Impressive win for the Packers, especially considering that same Bears team upended the Steelers in Week 3. Green Bay's defense, in particular, showed encouraging signs. As did Davante Adams, who is doing well after the vicious hit he took from Danny Trevathan. The player safety rules have been criticized by uninformed people. Hopefully, those who have taken issue with -- or made fun of -- those precautionary measures to protect players saw the hit, so as to appreciate why those rules are in place (even if the refs don't always get calls right). On another note: Green Bay plays at Dallas this Sunday, then at Minnesota. Big games.
Week 6: 3 up 2
So happy for Davante Adams, who suffered a concussion on a scary hit just 10 days before logging the game-winning catch on Sunday. While the Fox broadcast gushed over Aaron Rodgers -- which was deserved -- his receiver made a leaping, twisting grab to bring the Cowboys to their knees. And, as chronicled by colleague Michael Silver, it was Adams' suggestion to go right back to the same route, after Rodgers nearly threw an interception on it the previous play. Which brings us to another point: Adams' effort before the game-winning catch was as important -- when he did everything in his power to stop Jourdan Lewis from picking off Rodgers' errant pass. How may wideouts don't do that, especially on back-shoulder throws that inadvertently drift too far inside? By the way, Aaron Jones looks reeaaal nice, Clark.

Week 7: 15 down 12
No question, this is a huge drop. Yet, until we figure out what the Packers can do with backup quarterback Brett Hundley at the helm, this is where Green Bay sits. What I like: Hundley's comments post-loss, talking about his passion for football and not acting like a man who's afraid of replacing Aaron Rodgers in the wake of the franchise QB's broken collarbone. What I don't like: How many stars the NFL is losing to injury this year. Think about it: Eric Berry, David Johnson, J.J. Watt, Odell Beckham Jr., Rodgers. How about all the quality players just a rung beneath those names, like Ryan Tannehill, Whitney Mercilus and Dalvin Cook? Losing Rodgers for the season would be devastating, although the Pack did make the playoffs in 2013 without their franchise QB for half the year. Pulling for Hundley.
Week 8: 23 down 8
The Brett Hundley era, for however long it will last, started and then stalled (often) on Sunday. The defense kept the Packers in their game against the Saints throughout (with two early picks of Drew Brees), but Hundley simply could not get the Green Bay machine moving. Rookie running back Aaron Jones did his part, piling up 131 yards on 17 carries. Twitter was raving about the explosion on Jones' first run from scrimmage. Hundley showed burst of his own on that long touchdown scamper. But a severely reined-in game plan, combined with an underwhelming line (12 of 25 for 87 yards) from Hundley, doomed the Pack
Week 9: 23
How will coach Mike McCarthy alter the offense to suit what quarterback Brett Hundley can do well? Running the ball two downs and throwing to guys on slow-developing patterns won't keep the Pack in the hunt until (if) Aaron Rodgers comes back from his broken collarbone. Taking advantage of Hundley's mobility makes the most sense, as long as the rest of the offense (namely, McCarthy) can adjust. Don't misunderstand me: As a passer, Hundley is probably better from inside the pocket, where he can step up to avoid rushers without having to throw on the run. That said, utilizing some designed runs that the Pack would have never used with Rodgers could be effective.
Week 10: 26 down 3
Mike McCarthy has time invested in Brett Hundley -- going on three years, as a matter of fact. That doesn't mean he has faith in Hundley throwing more than 3 yards down the field. How will Green Bay adjust going forward? Maybe picking up the pace -- a la the two-minute drill or in garbage time against the Lions -- is the ticket. Hundley has the arm and can throw rolling out (somewhat) like his predecessor. Let him sink or swim. Hundley certainly knows the system. Unfortunately, everyone else knows the Pack can't get a pass rush without blitzing. (When they actually do, they should call it the "Pack rush!" Like Sacksonville!! Never mind.)

The season and the Murphy/Thompson/McCarthy/Capers Era has now hit rock bottom, at least for this week. For the first time and maybe ever since the “Wildness Years” the Packers are the worst team in the North Division (#6 Vikings; #16 Lions; #17 Bears) and almost the worst team in the National Conference ahead of the #29 Bucs, #30 49ers, and #31 Giants and almost the worst in the league also ahead of the #27 Bengals, #28 Dolphins and #32 Browns according to the official NFL Power Rankings.

How can a genius and future Hall of Fame General Manager build a team that was so dependent upon 1 player? I have been screaming from the  Wilderness since 2007 that Thompson had not only squandered one Hall of Fame quarterback twilight years,  but also built a House of Cards around another and that if it wasn’t for the play of a true future Hall of Famer the Packers were ordinary at best. Talk about a MVP for the ages.

But no one from "Miss The Mark" Murphy, to "Senile Ted" Thompson, to "Delusional Mike" McCarthy, to "Incompetent Dom" Capers and the local kiss ass media led by "Rhinelander Larry" McCarren (the Packers version of Saddam Hussein’s Baghdad Bob), who never calls out Murphy’s rosy scenarios, Capers or Thompson on their lack of answers and McCarthy’s weekly “all we have to do is fix it” crap, but digs deep to find “GOOD NEWS FAKE NEWS” to feed the faithful instead of ripping off the band aids to reveal the ugly “REAL NEWS” concerning the state of the 2017 Packers.


I have been saying this for years and finally some of the other Packer Backers are seeing the light, except for the “In Ted We Trust” militants. Their blind trust and abusement of those who don’t drink the water Ted Thompson walks on is far below the type of fans I thought the Packers had. With the rise of intolerance of our national politics over the past 9 years I guess the intolerants of the North Woods have been given a license to remove their balaclavas and step into the light since the spring of 2016 to shout down or send death threats to those who speak out against Thompson and his philosophy. I’m embarrassed by the “Tedders” and their ilk (for those of you in Rhinelander that means people like them).

A little over 7 years ago the Packers were riding high after winning the Super Bowl, but 1 man Thomas Hobbes writing for ALLGBP.com on August 23, 2011 joined me in wondering about Thompson and his methods. I recommend reading his prophetic plea about the general direction Thompson was taking the Packers and the rise of the “Tedders” movement: http://allgbp.com/2011/08/23/packers-fans-do-we-all-think-like-ted-thompson-now/

Hobbes starts with, “Now that General Manager Ted Thompson has won a Super Bowl using the “Thompson Method ™”, he can apparently do no wrong in the eyes of the fans.  People who had been clamoring for years to get more veteran free agents and big name signings have quieted down, ready to admit the error in their ways and venerate the white-haired one.  Even the most staunch Thompson hater is now ready to board the “draft and develop” bandwagon that Thompson preaches.” (Not all).

Hobbes finishes with: “I think it’s important as fans not to just blinding follow Thompson’s thinking.  When the Colts won the Super Bowl in 2008, many people were quick to venerate General Manager Bill Polian.  Colts fans were dismissive of linebackers (since Polian always seemed to manage to find good ones in the scrap heap of free agency) and overall people thought Polian was a genius.

Fast-forward to today and I think it has become apparent that the majority of the Colts dominance can be attributed more to quarterback Peyton Manning than Bill Polian.  Polian is a great General Manager but hasn’t managed to find a bona fide star in the first round since drafting Dallas Clark in 2003 (while other teams have managed to find stars in the bottom of the 1st round, like Aaron Rodgers 24th in 2005)

In the end, as a Packers fan, keep in mind that Ted Thompson is not a god and you shouldn’t blindly follow him; he’s a really good General Manager but he does not always know what he’s doing. Just look at Justin Harrell.”
Berres Brothers Coffee Roasters
Time to wake up and smell the Berres Brothers Coffee or sip full-bodied Sotéa tea and start a movement of our own to counter the “Tedders” and get the Packers back on track building a team around Aaron Rodgers before he retires or is let go when his contract comes up. You know Ted Thompson hates to spend $ and has a history of getting rid of malcontent players (anyone remember Brett Favre and Josh Sitton) and Rodgers has been talking out since last year.


If Favre and Sitton can be let go anyone can. Do you really want the face of the Packers to be Brett Hundley or Joe Callahan? The Packers were 4-1 going into the Vikings game and 3rd in the Power Rankings. After Rodgers was knocked out and the Packers lost with Hundley throwing 3 interceptions the Packers dropped to 15 with everyone thinking Rodgers means a lot to the Packers success.
 
The "In Ted We Trust" crowd is at it again (notice they used a running pic and not a passing one)
However, Thompson and McCarthy evidently thought Rodgers was nothing and their system is king, so Hundley could just step in and run the offensive machine that was averaging 27.4 points a game overall and 35 in each of the last 2 games, so, of course, Thompson did nothing to shore up the quarterback position.

In fact, Rodgers’ worth is at least 20 points a game, so it seems the genius Thompson and the greatest McCarthy are WRONG. Hundley is now officially 0-2, but I put him at 0-3 since he played the majority of the Vikings game averaging 14.6 a game and most of those points came in garbage time. The Packers are now 4-4 and sinking fast.

How the Mighty Have Fallen:
In fact again Vegas has installed the Da Bears (3-5) as the favorite for the 1st time this season. In fact a 3rd time, da Bears haven’t been a favorite over the Packers since 2008. In fact a 4th time (“Tedders” or their god Ted doesn’t like facts), the early line was 3 points before the loss to the Lions and is now 5 points. It might be 10 points by the noon kickoff on Sunday. SAD.

In injury related news right tackle Bryan Bulaga’s lost season is officially over after tearing his right ACL leaving guard Justin McCray as his permanent replacement. However, McCray injured his ankle on the last play Monday and his availability is uncertain, which means either tackle Ulrick John or guard Lucas Patrick will now be at right tackle. In addition former No. 2 pick Jason Spriggs was designated for return from injured reserve on Nov. 2, but hasn’t been activated as of yet.

Spriggs has been a bust at left tackle, John hasn’t played a down this season, but does have experience (he is a 3-year veteran having been a backup right tackle for the Dolphins for 2 games in 2015 and again for the Cardinals when he started for 3 games at right tackle because of an injury to the starter before he was lost for the season because of a shoulder injury. Thompson signed him off the Cardinals practice squad when right tackle Kyle Murphy was put on injured reserve. John has been with the Packers for 5 games being active for 1. He is a former 2014 No. 7 pick by the Colts) and Patrick is a left guard and backup center. There are NO tackles on the practice squad. Another genius move of many by Ted Thompson since the end of last season.

No comments:

Post a Comment